Every item on this page was chosen by an ELLE editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.
The skin on our faces is extremely fragile, especially the delicate area that surrounds our eyes. That’s why it’s no surprise that our under eyes tend to be the source of endless skincare problems, be it dark circles, puffy skin, or fine lines, to name a few. Of course, we can use eye creams and serums to target these issues, but another viable option is to consider using a pair of reusable eye masks.
“Having a good reusable eye mask that is 100% silicone is a must,” says Karina Sulzer, founder of Skin Gym. Sulzer explains that because of its material, reusable eye masks often allow for a deeper absorption of skincare products, whereas sheet masks can potentially feel too drying. The process is very straightforward: Apply your favorite under-eye product and place your reusable eye mask over the product for about 10 to 20 minutes. According to Sulzer, taking this extra step can help seal in the active ingredients of your eye creams and serums while revitalizing your under-eye skin.
And perhaps best of all, reusable eye masks are eco-friendly. Unlike ordinary eye masks that are designed to be discarded after one use, most reusable eye masks can last for months, even up to a year, if stored properly. Ahead, shop the seven best top-rated under-eye masks that will give your eye area a refresh.
Pros
Locks in moisture effectively
Cons
- Some reviewers note that the silicone feels stiff
Nowadays, my nighttime skincare routine isn’t complete without Skin Gym’s reusable eye patches, and the same goes for Sulzer. “There are so many benefits to using reusable eye masks, but my favorite feature about Skin Gym's eco-friendly under-eye reusable patches is that I am not wasting my pricey skincare ingredients with the continued use of disposable sheet masks,” says Sulzer. The Skin Gym founder says that these reusable eye masks lock in her hydrating products by keeping moisture in and decreasing evaporation.
Reusable limit: 100x
Ulta star rating: 4.8/5
An Ulta reviewer says: “These are fantastic eye masks! They moisturize my eyes and make my eyes feel very refreshed. Perfect for taking a bath or laying down to watch a movie. They make a great gift for friends too.”
Best Long-Lasting Reusable Eye Mask
Dieux Forever Eye Mask
Pros
- Can last for up to a year
Cons
- Silicone feels thin
The magic of this product is in the name. Dieux’s Forever Eye Masks can last up to an entire year, so say goodbye to disposable sheet masks. If you’re a makeup fanatic, you’ll love these masks, as they are also designed to catch makeup fallout, preventing residue from eyeshadow, eyeliner, and mascara from falling below the eye.
Reusable limit: One year
Amazon rating: 4.8/5 stars
An Amazon reviewer said: “Love these eye mask! I can use whatever serum or eye cream that I would like to meet my needs at the time and have no waste! Sounds like a win/win to me!”
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Increases maximum absorption
Cons
- Can’t wear overnight
While scrolling through TikTok, I saw a video of someone raving about 4AM Skincare's reusable eye masks. The video gained over 1 million views, so naturally, I had to see what the hype was about. After going down a rabbit hole of searching, I soon realized that reviewers are absolutely in love with this product because it delivers on its promise of helping to boost hydration and plump fine lines.
Reusable limit: One year
Revolve star rating: 4.1/5
A Revolve reviewer says: “They stick perfectly I love!! I also have a small face and i feel like they fit really well.”
Best Cooling Reusable Eye Mask
Face Freezie Reusable Cooling Undereye Patches
Pros
- Cooling effect
Cons
- Some reviewers note that it can be a bit slippery
Planning to have an at-home spa day? You’ll want to use these cryotherapy-inspired Face Freezie cooling patches. For best results, place these patches in the refrigerator for around 20 minutes or more, and then apply them to your face for an ultra-soothing feel.
Reusable limit: 10x
Ulta star rating: 4.2/5
An Ulta reviewer says: “My absolute favorite under eye patch! Leaves your eyes feeling cool and refreshing! I've noticed such a difference with my eye bags! I love that it's reusable and super easy to use! 10/10!”
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Strong adhesive effect
Cons
- Only lasts for around 10 uses
Pacifica’s reusable under-eye masks promise a vacuum-like seal that will instantly lock in your under-eye cream or serum. How does this work? Thanks to the adhesive silicone material, these masks have a firm grip, so there’s no need to worry about the patches slipping off.
Reusable limit: 10x
Ulta star rating: 4.3/5An
An Ulta reviewer says: “I have not worn overnight, but have allowed to stay on for more than an hour when my under eyes were extra puffy and allergic. These really help when paired with the caffeine serum and keeping the eye pads in the refrigerator. I see improvement and happy to have less waste than the standard throw away pads.”
Pros
- Targets two areas
Cons
- Might take time to see results
Dealing with lip lines, as well as fine lines around your eyes, is a pain. Sio Beauty’s Eye & Smile Superlift patches will work to target both areas. For a plumped and refreshed look, you’ll want to incorporate these patches into your daily skincare routine.
Reusable limit: 10x
Sio Beauty star rating: 4.4/5
A Sio Beauty reviewer says: “I love these patches! I’m a side sleeper, and these are amazing at preventing sleep lines.”
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Best Tech-Savvy Reusable Eye Mask
Conair Cool Beanz Reusable Under Eye Patches
Pros
- Helps to de-puff under eyes
Cons
- The device requires a charger
A chilled reusable eye mask is an instant pick-me-up for puffy eyes. Conair’s innovative eye mask set is a tech-savvy package that comes with a compact cooling case that works to cool eye masks in under five minutes. After applying your chilled masks, you’ll notice an instant de-puffed appearance.
Reusable limit: 30x
Amazon star rating: 4.1/5
An Amazon reviewer says: “I used to spend so much money on eye masks, I never realized that all I really needed was good serum. It’s so much more environmentally friendly than other beauty products. Since it’s reusable, I can target anything I want whether it be brightening or hydrating. Worth a purchase.”
What’s the difference between sheet masks and reusable masks?
The difference boils down to the material. Sheet masks are made of materials like fiber, cotton, and cellulose, which are infused with a formula of hydrating ingredients. On the other hand, reusable masks are made of silicone, and they’re usually not infused with anything. Instead, they’re intended to work in tandem with other skincare products. “Silicone masks aren't able to absorb products, so I love that all my skincare products are being used to their fullest potential,” says Sulzer. “I also appreciate how they don't dry out easily and can be repurposed and reused,“ she adds.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
How long do reusable eye masks last?
The answer to this question fully depends on the product that you decided to purchase. Some reusable eye masks last for around 10 uses, while others claim to last for up to a year. No matter how long you end up using your reusable eye masks, always make sure to properly cleanse your masks with light soap and water after each use to avoid bacteria accumulation and residue build-up.
Why Trust ELLE Beauty?
As a leading publisher of fashion, lifestyle, and beauty content, ELLE.com is committed to highlighting the best products in various categories by personally testing the latest and most innovative products, interviewing countless experts, and vetting customer-loved items. For this piece, Lauren Tappan scoured the internet while reading numerous reviews to find the best reusable under eye masks.
